This
album improves on the first. Two things are noticeable - there's a monster
guitarist playing on some of the tracks which are heavier than on the first
album, secondly there is a sense of humour. The similarity with the first
album is the hauntingly beautiful music represented by The Fields Of Robert
John.
Paul Mounsey has kindly corrected some
of my notes and he has also given me some notes he made about NahooToo
which I have incorporated into the page. Paul does not like discussing
his work, he would rather that people made their own interpretations of
the music, but I find that this insight brings an extra dimension
to the album. On the album as a whole he said:
'I think the album can be divided
into two parts. The first part is about the idea of 'clearance' in general,
whether it be in the Highlands of Scotland, Brasil, the US or anywhere
else. All the tracks attempt to approach that subject in some way. The
first part ends with Psalm. Turned On The Dog is a kind of entr'acte/intermission/link
thing quite distinct from the overall discourse of the album - a bit of
trivial fun to disperse any possible pretentiousness. The second part begins
with Nahoo and, as far as I know, has no real coherent concept behind it.
The exception would be Red River, which is related to the first part in
that Red River is a place in Canada (Manitoba) where a group of cleared
highlanders from Sutherland were massacred by indians in 185? or thereabouts.'
The sleeve is Different heads by Gill
Vicente courtesy of the Futuro 25 Gallery in Brazil. Iona IRCD050, 1997
- Remembrance (Paul Mounsey) 05:27
- the lyrics are part Cavante, and part Yanomami (native Brazilian languages).The
final phrases are in Gaelic, repeated in Portuguese. The instruments are
Urua flutes and bagpipes. The whole thing rocks along - at first the vocals
are discordant but the more you listen to it the more the music makes sense.
Not an easy listen but worth persevering with.
'An opening statement. The Scottish element,
reflected in the Gaelic text and the pipes, refers to a cleared highlander
from Portree in the 1850s setting sail for Canada. This is mirrored in
references to the 'cleared' indians of Brazil, through the Uruá
flute and the vocals. The connection is established.'(Paul Mounsey)
- Wherever You Go (Paul Mounsey) 05:04
- this time all the lyrics are in English, sung by Paul Mounsey and Luis
Henrique. This is much easier to listen to than the first track. No traditional
instruments here, and Serj plays a pretty mean electric guitar.
- North (Paul Mounsey) 05:44 - American
radio or TV broadcasts form a background to this beautiful piece of violin
music by Maria Ester Brandao with Ilda Chaves Sergi providing a haunting
soprano. Half way through good old Serj appears with a heavy guitar piece
as a contrast. Finally there is a reprise of the violin theme. That sounds
like three different tracks - or even three different CDs, but it works
- I guess you have to hear it.
'And so to the crux of the matter. The Highland
Clearances have provided a fertile ground indeed for folklore to romanticise
the predicament of the highlander, transforming him into a victim of mythic
proportions. The focus is always on the poor, down-trodden crofter forced
off the land, obliged to set sail for another country. Little, or nothing,
is said about the atrocities committed by those very same highlanders once
they arrived in their new-found land. The cleared became the clearers;
the exploited became the exploiters; and it is easy to understand how a
Native American would see the Highland Clearances in a completely different
light'. 'This song makes specific reference to the Cree, Mohawk and Inuit
peoples.' (Paul Mounsey)
- Infinite Contempt (Paul Mounsey)
05:05 - once again Serj's guitar is contrasted with traditional fiddle
(it says violin in the sleeve notes).
'It's what you see in the eyes of the children
of the down-trodden. I've seen it on indian reservations in the Amazon,
in Arizona, in North Dakota. I've seen it all over Africa. I've never seen
it in Europe. It's a look that is inherited, not learned. This track is
sung from the point of view of the exploiter.' (Paul Mounsey)
- Another Clearance (Paul Mounsey)
04:57 - an instrumental - it's Paul Mounsey so it has to be a haunting
mix of traditional music from Scotland and North American Indian chants
backed in places with a pretty mean percussion section - no credit is given
for this so I think it must be a sample.
'Again, Scottish and Native American aspects
are blended in an attempt to throw a different light on the Scottish element.'
(Paul Mounsey)
Kaiwa Farewell (Paul Mounsey) 05:02
- starting off with an intro not unlike Tubular Bells this is another song
about the Highland Clearances, partly in English and partly in spoken Tupi.
Paul Mounsey takes impossibly incompatible sounds and blends them into
a beautiful track.
'It's the only track on the album that was
written as a spontaneous reaction to something. In the state of Mato Grosso
in western Brasil, there is a tribe of indians called the Guaraní-Kaiwá.
They are literally killing themselves off out of despair. They are poor,
have no land, no prospects of ever participating in white man's society,
and when they manage to get work it's little more than slave labor. The
suicide rate among them is much higher proportionately than that of Hungary,
number one suicide country in the world. And the highest rate is among
the adolescents. Anthropologists have been studying this phenomenon for
years and the United Nations has instigated an investigation but many more
will die before something concrete is done. The phenomenon has been labelled
"The Silent Rebellion". This is not an isolated case. Mass suicide among
Native Brazilians can be found in a number of regions.' (Paul Mounsey)
- Psalm (Paul Mounsey, traditional)
01:41 - a little guitar instrumental.
- Turned On The Dog (Paul Mounsey)
02:38 - this is so funny. A heavy rock intro is suddenly interrupted by
a mild female Scottish voice and then restarts. At the end this very proper
Scottish voice says that she got carried away .... well I guess you have
to hear it. The track is Serj on a Mammoth guitar really letting rip with
a
little backing from bagpipes.
- Nahoo (Paul Mounsey, traditional)
05:59 - a song about a sailor who returns home to find that his love is
not there.
- The Fields Of Robert John (Paul Mounsey
) 04:30 - this is the track most played by Bob Harris. If you want to be
convinced that you should buy it this is the track you should listen to
- it is so beautiful...
'About a hundred miles north of São
Paulo there is a little town called Campos do Jordão (literally
Fields of Jordan), a popular holiday resort among the affluent upper-middle
class of São Paulo. Few people know that the town owes its existence
today to a Scotsman called Robert John Reid of Inverness. At the beginning
of this century he was hired to do a surveying job for a French firm. Before
he could finish the job the firm went bust and they ended up paying him
with the very land he was surveying. This Scot was responsible for building
the school, the hospital, bringing both the railroad and the highway to
the town. He devoted the rest of his life to the place and eventually died
penniless. He is "remembered" today by a street that carries his name.'
(Paul Mounsey)
- Fall (Paul Mounsey, 'The Little Cascade'
- W. MacLennan) 04:03 - another haunting piece of music
- A Mhairead Og (Young Margaret) 1 (
Traditional arranged Paul Mounsey) 01:07 - a traditional ballad sung in
Gaelic and English by Flora MacNeil backed by Paul Mounsey on keyboards
with heavier instrumental breaks interspersed with and intertwining with
the folk song.
- A Mhairead Og (Young Margaret) 2 (
Paul Mounsey, traditional) 04:18 - Paul tells me that the difference between
traditional arranged by Paul Mounsey and Paul Mounsey/Traditional is really
for copyright purposes.
- Red River (Paul Mounsey) 03:14 -
This track features a rather nice bottleneck guitar, bringing in a piece
of violin/flute music, wonderfully evocative. The flutes are played by
Teco Cardoso and are transverse flutes, Brazilian wooden flutes and a tin
whistle.
- Hope You're Not Guilty (Paul Mounsey
) 04:41 - once again samples from radio/TV/movies introduce this track
and then form the background. I'm afraid that this time I find the repeated
samples irritating
'Not to be taken seriously. Having watched
too much CNN one night, I called on Bill Clinton, Bob Dole, Fernando Collor
(our impeached President), the wife of the Oklahoma bomber, a crazy TV
evangelist, a hooker and a cast of thousands to provide the lyrics about
this one. After so much bullshit, all that remained was to have an entire
football stadium tell them all where to stick it!' (Paul Mounsey)
- Nahoo Reprise (Traditional arranged
Paul Mounsey) 03:55 - not much more to say than - it's a reprise of Nahoo!
- Lullaby (Tim Young, Paul Mounsey)
03:06 - sounds rather like a Clannad track. No heavy guitar, no samples
- it's a lullaby.
'aka Lullaby For Denis. To round things
off, a song for all the street kids everywhere. We have more than our fair
share here in São Paulo. Late one night I saw Denis (no more than
8 years old) alone at his usual corner, standing in the pouring rain crying
his eyes out. No shelter, no future, no point.' (Paul Mounsey)
|